How to Follow Up With Zillow and Realtor.com Leads

A practical follow-up plan for Zillow and Realtor.com leads: what to say in the first five minutes, the next seven days and the months after.

Couple browsing homes for sale on a laptop at home, the moment a Zillow or Realtor.com inquiry reaches a real estate agent
Portal buyers often contact two or three agents about the same home. Photo: Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash.

In short

  • Reply to Zillow and Realtor.com leads within minutes, about the exact home they asked about, with two showing times.
  • Follow up on day one, day three and day seven, then move quiet leads to a monthly touch.
  • Most portal buyers contact several agents, so consistency beats charm.

Leads from Zillow and Realtor.com are some of the best an agent can get, and some of the hardest to convert. They show up at all hours, they usually ask about one specific home, and they often contacted two or three agents at once. The good news is that a simple, consistent follow-up plan beats talent and charm almost every time.

Listing card for a three bedroom home at 214 Maple Ave next to a four step follow-up plan for portal leads: minute one, day one, day three and day seven
A simple follow-up plan for portal leads, from the first minute to the first week.

Here is the plan we see work, in the order you would use it.

Before anything else: know where the lead came from

Portal leads arrive in a few different ways depending on how you buy them: an email notification, a text alert, a push notification in the portal’s app, or a feed into your CRM. Make sure every one of those lands in one place you actually watch. A lead you never saw is the slowest lead of all.

Write down the home they asked about, the price, and anything they typed in the message box. You will use all of it in your first reply.

Minute one: reply to the question they asked

Most portal inquiries boil down to “Is this still available?” or “Can I see it?” Cover that first, specifically, then make the next step easy.

A first text that works:

“Hi Maria, this is Dana with Reed Realty. 214 Maple Ave is still available. I can show it Saturday at 10 or Sunday at 1. Does either of those work for you?”

Notice what is not in there: no long introduction, no request to “hop on a quick call,” no questions about their finances yet. You earn those questions by being helpful first.

Send an email too if you have their address. Some people never check texts from unknown numbers but will open an email that mentions the house by name.

Day one: a light check-in

If there is no reply, wait until the next day and send one short message. Keep it about the home, not about you.

“Hi Maria, just checking whether you still wanted to see Maple this weekend. Saturday at 10 is still open.”

One message. Not three. If they are interested, this is often the one they reply to.

Day three: give them something new

By now they may have seen the house online, gone off it, or found another one. Send one or two similar homes in the same area and price range. This shows you are paying attention to what they want, not just to the listing that generated the lead.

“Two homes just came up that are close to what you asked about: 418 Birch Lane, 3 bed, and 22 Cedar Ct with a bigger yard. Want me to set up times for either?”

Day seven: ask if they are still looking

A simple, honest question gets surprisingly good response rates:

“Are you still looking for a home in the area, or should I check back in a few months?”

Both replies are useful. A yes restarts the conversation. A “not yet” tells you their timeline, and you can follow up when it actually matters to them.

After the first week: a steady, low-key touch

A lot of portal leads are early. They are browsing six months or a year before they move. Put them on a monthly touch: a couple of new listings that match, a note when a home they asked about drops in price, or a quick market update for the neighborhood. The goal is to be the agent they remember when they are ready.

Common mistakes with portal leads

  • Asking for a call in the first message. Many buyers are not ready to talk. Let them text.
  • Leading with pre-approval questions. Ask about timing and the home first. Financing comes up naturally once there is a real conversation.
  • Giving up after one try. Most conversations start on the second or third message, not the first.
  • Sending the same text to everyone. Mention the home, the street, or one detail from their message. It takes ten seconds and makes a big difference.

Putting the plan on autopilot

The plan above is simple. Doing it for every lead, at 11 PM on a Tuesday and during your Sunday open house, is the hard part. That is the job Clanlio takes off your plate.

Leads from Zillow, Realtor.com, Homes.com, social lead ads and your website get a reply within minutes from your own email and number. Clanlio replies to the question about the home, offers showing times from your real calendar, follows up when the lead goes quiet, and alerts you when someone is ready. Every conversation is in your dashboard and your CRM, and you can step in whenever you like. See how each source connects on the Integrations page.

Related guides

Respond to every lead with Clanlio

Clanlio is AI lead follow-up for real estate agents. It texts and emails every new buyer and seller lead within minutes, in your name, qualifies them on timeline, budget, area and pre-approval, and books showings on your calendar.

  • Solo plan: for individual agents. Set up in about 10 minutes and respond to your next buyer or seller lead within minutes.
  • Brokerage plan: instant replies and lead routing for real estate teams and brokerages.
  • Compare all plans, including Enterprise for large brokerages.

Frequently asked questions

How quickly should I respond to a Zillow lead?

Within five minutes is a good target. Buyers often contact several agents from the same listing page, and the first useful reply usually starts the conversation.

How many times should I follow up with a portal lead?

Three or four times in the first week is reasonable: the first reply, a check-in the next day, new homes around day three and a “still looking?” around day seven. After that, a monthly touch is enough.

What if the home they asked about is already under contract?

Say so right away and offer one or two similar homes in the same message. Buyers appreciate a straight reply, and it keeps the conversation going.

Want a reply to your portal leads tonight? Start your free trial or read the FAQ first.

#lead sources #Realtor.com #Zillow

Respond to every lead in minutes, day or night

Clanlio texts and emails every new lead from your own number and address, qualifies them and books showings on your calendar.

Get Started Free See pricing